Our History
1791: Humble Beginnings in Faith
The story of the United Methodist Church of Patchogue begins in 1791, during the presidency of George Washington. That same year, a group of devoted Methodists gathered in the home of Ezra Tuttle in Blue Point to worship, study scripture, and build a faith community. Though they started small, their faith laid the foundation for a church that would stand for generations.
1891: A Sanctuary Built to Last
Our current church home—a stunning Romanesque-style brick sanctuary—was completed in 1891 at the corner of South Ocean Avenue and Church Street. Designed by architect Oscar Teale, the building features beautiful stained glass, intricate woodwork, and a timeless design that continues to inspire. In 1984, the church was added to the National Register of Historic Places, a lasting tribute to its architectural and spiritual significance.
A Living Legacy of Love
For over two centuries, the United Methodist Church of Patchogue has remained a place of worship, welcome, and witness. We honor our past by continuing to serve the community with open hearts, open minds, and open doors.
Under the leadership of Rev. Dr. Debbie San Pablo, our church continues to grow in faith, reach out in love, and follow where God leads us next.